John Flavel’s preaching changed when he lost the right to exercise his ministry in the usual places. The practical language he continued to use was familiar to the people of a maritime town.
Dartmouth and a Costly Choice
In 1656, Flavel left Diptford for Dartmouth. The early account explains the move as the acceptance of a wider field of service, though one offering a smaller income. That decision gives substance to what might otherwise be a general statement of dedication. Greater responsibility did not come with financial advantage. We need not imagine a negotiation or an inward debate: the contrast between the two situations is significant in itself. At Dartmouth his life would become durably connected with the community repeatedly addressed in his books.
The early account connects the invitation with Flavel’s previous service as moderator at a provincial synod. Anthony Hartford, Dartmouth’s minister, reportedly recognized his ability there, became his friend, and recommended his work. After Hartford’s death, Flavel was chosen for the community. The same account records the ratification of his service by an order from Whitehall dated December 10, 1656. Working alongside Allen Geare, also spelled Allein Geere, he shared the duties: preaching on Sundays at Townstall and taking alternate turns at the Wednesday instruction in the town. His establishment involved colleagues, hearers, and defined responsibilities.
Dartmouth also becomes visible in the readers he addressed. By dedicating a book to shipmasters and seamen belonging to Clifton, Dartmouth, and Hardness, Flavel chose a specific audience. The maritime world supplied his readers with familiar activities, dangers, and language. He would use that language to make matters of faith intelligible. Before examining the book, we should notice the commitment behind it: he had gone to a community, and his teaching needed to reach the people actually living there. The setting of his ministry became part of the form his writing took.
1662: Losing His Official Ministry
The restoration of the monarchy in 1660 changed the setting of Flavel’s ministry. The Church of England regained its institutional position, and uniformity in worship became a matter of public authority. In May 1662 Parliament passed a new Act of Uniformity associated with the revised Book of Common Prayer. For Flavel, the change had a direct consequence: that year he was removed from his parish ministry because he did not conform to the requirements. The community he served remained, but his official position had been taken away.
The term Nonconformist describes this relationship to the established religious order. It does not mean that every minister so identified held identical opinions. Flavel’s formation and convictions were connected with Reformed Protestantism and Presbyterian ministry. The early biography records that he continued preaching and administering the sacraments privately. Losing his position did not lead him to abandon the congregation’s care. His service continued under different conditions and fresh restrictions.
Allen Geare died that December. The colleague who had worked with Flavel in Dartmouth was gone only months after the ministers’ removal. The community’s story now included institutional disruption and the loss of someone who had shared in its care. Continuing private preaching did not undo those events. It did show that Flavel distinguished permission to hold a public position from the responsibility he believed he had received before God. That commitment would be tested again when restrictions also affected his ability to remain near his hearers.
Slapton and the Roads of Persecution
In 1665 new restrictions narrowed the space available to dissenting ministers. The Five Mile Act sought to keep them away from certain towns and parishes where they had ministered. Flavel moved to Slapton, near Dartmouth. Geographical separation was added to removal from office. A community whose pastor could no longer minister publicly had already undergone a profound change; requiring him to live elsewhere created another practical difficulty for the relationship they were trying to preserve.
The account of his life describes an occasion when he was preaching in a wood near Exeter and the authorities interrupted the gathering. Some participants were detained; the biography mentions a tanner who received a fine. Flavel escaped and, according to the account, continued preaching in another wood with those who accompanied him. The episode comes through the biographical tradition, without a police record examined here to establish every detail. As an account, it nevertheless reveals one dimension of persecution: risk extended to hearers and supporters as well as the preacher.
If you want to see what a preacher does when the familiar place of meeting is taken away, the Faith Ablaze app is a place to continue the reading. The member library brings together biographies and studies of preaching and pastoral life that you can explore and revisit at your own pace. Explore the Faith Ablaze app.
The dedication to Keeping the Heart supplies direct testimony to the separation. Flavel describes his absence as enforced and insists that his relationship with Dartmouth’s Christians continues. Writing served that effort. A book could be revisited when he could no longer repeat his teaching in person; it could recall what distance threatened to weaken. Here we find a concrete consequence of persecution for his work: separation made it still more important to leave counsel that remained accessible to the community.
Keeping the Heart in Unstable Times
According to Flavel himself, the book known as Keeping the Heart began with a request for help. A friend experiencing inward distress brought him a difficulty and asked for guidance. As Flavel considered that situation, other related questions arose. Friends requested copies; others wanted the work published. This account of its beginnings places the book close to pastoral counseling. A particular case led to instructions that might serve others, although we do not know the friend’s name and cannot assign a modern diagnosis.
Flavel chose the exhortation in Proverbs to keep the heart as his foundation. He explained that heart, in this usage, encompassed the inward person: understanding, memory, and conscience were also involved. Keeping it meant attending to the source of actions, desires, and choices. The task included self-examination, repentance, prayer, and awareness of God’s presence. It was not presented as an achievement independent of grace. For him, the responsibility was human, but the ability to fulfill it depended on Christ’s help. Inward care had to remain connected with the source of Christian life.
His severity should not obscure an important distinction in the text itself. Imagining a Christian troubled by an inability to prevent every distraction in prayer, Flavel answered that resisting inward disorder differed from settling comfortably into it. Difficulty did not automatically establish hypocrisy. His analysis allowed for a sincere conscience that still experienced weakness. This attention to differences among readers makes the book more complex than a demand for self-control. The pastor sought to awaken the indifferent while preventing distressed believers from falling into despair because they had not attained perfection.
The Language of Seafarers
In Navigation Spiritualized, Flavel addressed men who worked at sea with particular attention. Its title announced a new compass for seamen. The work was organized into thirty-two points, with observations, applications, and reflections accompanied by poems. Its form sought to connect the reader’s familiar world with spiritual instruction. Speaking about eternal matters did not require abandoning the vocabulary of work. Flavel wanted to meet his readers within language they could understand.
He explained this intention in his dedication. He had tried to clothe spiritual matters in seafarers’ expressions, making them more intelligible. His assessment of many sailors’ habits is severe, shaped by a call to repentance and fear of judgment. At the same time, he addressed them as someone desiring their salvation. Familiar images served more than an ornamental purpose. This was a choice in pastoral communication: using what readers knew to help them consider the direction of their lives.
At the dedication’s close, he expressed the hope that they would return transformed, bringing home more than the material results of a voyage. Maritime language thus served a spiritual hope. We should resist, however, turning every storm or danger mentioned in the book into a personal recollection by the author. There are comparisons and exercises in reflection, as well as an additional epistle signed by another contributor. Flavel’s contribution is clear enough in his own introductory words: he adapted his teaching to the people for whom he took responsibility. Attention to his audience was part of his care.
Reading the evidence
The surviving record lets us see what a preacher does when the familiar place of meeting is taken away. Those details give the account its limits as well as its shape. They let a reader ask what the decisions meant for the people who had to live with them.
Go deeper into the questions raised by John Flavel with books, study guides, and audio and video resources in the Faith Ablaze app. Your membership also helps our team share more stories that recover the people and places behind a preacher’s words through free articles and YouTube documentaries. Become a member and help keep these stories available.
Selected sources
Navigation Spiritualized; or A New Compass for Seamen, The Whole Works,vol.V,pp206–217seçõesiniciais.
The Life of the late Rev. Mr. John Flavel, minister of Dartmouth.
A Saint Indeed; or Keeping the Heart, Richmond: Joseph Martin,1826.
