The agreement associated with Schleitheim tells us what a community wanted to practice. The proceedings against Michael Sattler tell us what some authorities thought they had to prevent.
Schleitheim: A Brotherly Union
On February 24,1527, a gathering at Schleitheim produced the agreement known as the Brotherly Union or Schleitheim Confession. Sattler is widely recognized as its principal drafter. The document nevertheless speaks collectively: brothers and sisters communicate their agreement about Christian life. The assembly should not disappear so that the text becomes a private declaration by its best-known contributor.
The seven subjects were baptism, discipline, breaking bread, separation, pastors, the sword, and the oath. Their selection reveals the gathering’s urgent concerns. The participants were not offering a complete exposition of Christian theology. They needed to clarify how their congregations should live together and respond to religious and civil demands contrary to their understanding of discipleship.
The document’s framework joins consolation, peace, and responsibility. Its participants wanted to strengthen troubled consciences, correct conflicts, and remain united in Christ. Language about forgiveness and grace accompanies its demands for obedience. Preserving that combination prevents a later reading from reducing it to a list of prohibitions. Its discipline looked toward the life of a people who understood themselves as reached by Christ and called to follow him.
Baptism, Discipline, and a Shared Table
The first article connects baptism with repentance, faith in Christ’s work, and a desire to walk in a changed life. It therefore excludes infant baptism. The point was more than postponing a ceremony: it joined the outward sign with the recipient’s commitment. This conviction also defined the boundaries of the gathered congregation.
The second article addresses correction when someone fell into sin. It provides for warnings and, when necessary, congregational exclusion according to the group’s reading of Matthew 18. This discipline was to precede the Supper. The congregation did not want to celebrate unity while ignoring a rupture in conduct it considered serious. Exclusion was not therefore socially harmless or free from dangers, but its form of correction differed from bodily punishment imposed by a court.
The third article connects breaking bread with remembrance of Christ’s body and blood and membership in the same body. Baptism, commitment, and communion belong together. The shared table is not presented as an act detached from participants’ lives. The document seeks to hold together what practice can separate: confessing Christ, living responsibly with fellow believers, and sharing bread. In this vision, the church should make its unity visible through a common life.
The Sword and the Truth of One’s Word
The sixth article presents one of the agreement’s most distinctive positions. It recognizes a role for the sword in civil order but places it outside what it calls the perfection of Christ. For the community of disciples, it proposes correction without bodily death. Christ’s way of suffering and calling people to repentance provides the measure for his followers.
From this reading follow rejection of violence and refusal of a Christian’s holding the magistrate’s office. Anabaptists did not all share the same political understanding: Balthasar Hubmaier, for example, defended a different position on the sword. Schleitheim helped form a particular, influential approach. Sattler’s refusal did not depend on first possessing enough force to prevail and then choosing peace. It was a principle intended to hold under vulnerability as well.
If you want to compare the life a confession described with the pressures that tested it, the Faith Ablaze app is a place to continue the reading. The member library brings together biographies and historical studies of conscience under pressure that you can explore and revisit at your own pace. Explore the Faith Ablaze app.
The seventh article rejects oaths, taking seriously the requirement that one’s word be truthful. This affected important civil practices in which swearing could confirm loyalty or obligation. The authors did not intend to free disciples to lie. They required truthfulness that did not depend on an added religious guarantee. Commitment to Christ reached both the way one faced an enemy and the way one said yes or no.
Love in the Prison Letter
A central part of the letter warns against forgetting love. Sattler draws on the description in 1 Corinthians 13 and applies it to congregational correction: caring for another believer should not become pride or self-interest. Doctrinal firmness needed mercy toward the weak. This teaching deserves attention within a tradition often remembered only for demanding separation.
The letter also retains severe language against people he considers false brothers and a strong expectation that history’s fulfillment is near. Removing those elements to produce a pastor perfectly suited to present-day sensibilities would misrepresent him. His hope was apocalyptic and his understanding of community rigorous. At the same time, he urged prayer, regular gathering, assistance to those in need, and care for workers driven from their homes.
Near the end, he asked the believers to care for his wife if he were killed and requested prayer for prisoners. He did not present his own survival as indispensable to the work: the Lord could raise up another worker. There is particular strength in this combination of farewell and continuity. Sattler faced the possibility of death while leaving the congregation responsibilities it could still fulfill. The faith he professed needed to remain alive in love practiced after his absence.
The Charge Concerning War
One particularly serious charge concerned a possible Turkish invasion. The account attributes to Sattler the position that armed resistance should not be offered. It also preserves the provocative statement that, if warfare were legitimate, he would rather fight the so-called Christians who persecuted believers. Such language made his position especially offensive to authorities expecting religious and political loyalty.
His response must be heard within his rejection of warfare. Sattler was not presenting a plan for armed insurrection. The hypothetical argument exposed what he saw as the contradiction of people professing Christ while persecuting others for their faith. The account also retains hostile language about the Turks and his accusers. We can explain the argument without adopting those expressions as an impartial description of peoples and religions.
Refusing the sword did not eliminate the severity of his judgment on opponents. Nonviolence here coexisted with hard words. Even so, the practical choice was decisive: Sattler maintained that a disciple should not kill to preserve his position. His appeal to Christ’s authority brought him into conflict with civil demands that rulers considered indispensable to protecting public order.
Reading the evidence
The surviving record lets us compare the life a confession described with the pressures that tested it. Those details give the account its limits as well as its shape. They let a reader ask what the decisions meant for the people who had to live with them.
Go deeper into the questions raised by Michael Sattler with books, study guides, and audio and video resources in the Faith Ablaze app. Your membership also helps our team share more carefully researched stories about the costs of Christian conviction through free articles and YouTube documentaries. Become a member and help keep these stories available.
Selected sources
Brüderliche Vereinigung,1527, transcrição em German History in Documents and Images.
Sattler, Michael, HLS,16/2/2011.
Michael Sattler’s Trial,1527, excerto universitário de ediçãoHeraldPress1987,pp416–418.
Carta da prisão à comunidade de Horb,1527, transcrição alemã, parteII,cap2.9.
